The Dufresnes

Looking for our complete Holafly guide? We've personally used Holafly eSIMs in 10 countries and Holafly Plans in 6 countries. Our main Holafly guide includes our latest discount code, honest review, setup instructions, FAQs, travel tips, and the newest Holafly Plans features.
→ Read our complete Holafly guide here: https://thedufresnestravel.com/pages/holafly 

  

Most articles about staying connected in New York tell you to "get an eSIM" and move on. This one is different: it's a decision guide. Because the real question in NYC isn't whether you need data — the subway, the five boroughs, and the sheer density of the place answer that for you — it's which option you pick, and how to avoid the one mistake that quietly costs international visitors the most money.

That mistake is roaming. So let's start there.

The quick call: for most visitors, a Holafly USA eSIM with code THEDUFRESNES (5% off) beats both airport SIM counters and home-carrier roaming. 👉 Get it here · 📺 how it works

The roaming trap, explained

Here's the pattern that gets people. You fly into JFK from London or Frankfurt or Tokyo, your phone connects to a US network automatically, and it just… works. No prompt, no decision, no queue. Great, right?

Then the bill arrives. Because "it just worked" often means your home carrier quietly switched you onto pay-as-you-go international roaming, and a week of navigating New York on maps, rideshare, and translation can turn into a genuinely ugly line item. The trap isn't that roaming is expensive — everyone knows it's expensive — it's that it's invisible and automatic. You never chose it. You just landed, used your phone like normal, and paid for it later.

An eSIM flips that: you decide in advance, you know the price up front, and roaming never gets the chance to switch itself on.

Your three options, and who each is actually for

Not everyone should buy the same thing. Here's the honest breakdown.

Option A — Home-carrier roaming. Effortless, and occasionally fine if your plan happens to include the US at a flat daily rate you've actually checked. For most international visitors it doesn't, and the default per-day rates make it the most expensive way to spend a week in New York. Verdict: only if you've confirmed your plan includes US roaming cheaply — otherwise, avoid.

Option B — A SIM at the airport. You can buy a local SIM at a JFK/Newark/LaGuardia counter. But it means queuing after a long-haul flight (international arrivals lines are the worst), swapping your physical SIM, and often overpaying for a tourist package. Verdict: the slow, old-fashioned choice.

Option C — A Holafly eSIM, installed before you fly. You set it up at home, and the moment you land you switch off airplane mode and you're online in about 30 seconds — no queue, no SIM swap, no bill shock, and your home number stays active in the phone for calls and 2FA codes. Verdict: the right pick for most people, which is why the rest of this guide assumes it.

What it costs — and why "unlimited" is the right shape for NYC

The USA eSIM is unlimited data, priced by the number of days, with 5% off via THEDUFRESNES:

Trip length	Price	With THEDUFRESNES
A weekend (5 days)	$20.50	$19.48
A week (7 days)	$27.50	$26.13
Ten days	$36.50	$34.68
Two weeks (15 days)	$50.50	$47.98

Any duration from 1 to 90 days. Here's why unlimited specifically fits New York, as opposed to a cheaper capped plan: NYC isn't a big-download city, it's a constant-small-lookup city. Real-time subway status because a line's rerouted for weekend work. The right exit at a station with a dozen of them. A rideshare when the train's not cooperating. A restaurant that isn't a Times Square trap. Live map traffic before you commit to a spot. None of it is heavy — but you're doing it all day, and the value of unlimited is that you never hesitate to do the next lookup because you're rationing. That hesitation is what a capped plan quietly costs you.

If you're crossing into Canada or Mexico on the same trip, that's the one case to not buy the USA-only eSIM — there's a North America eSIM that covers all three. And if you're a frequent US visitor, Holafly Plans work out better over a year ($58.41/month, or roughly $595/year — up to 26% off). Every plan includes Always On backup data too — 1 GB a month that keeps you reachable even between trips.

One thing to know before you count on sharing: the USA eSIM tethers about 1 GB a day to a second device — fine for a partner's maps and messaging, not for running a household of devices. For heavy hotspot use, Plans Unlimited is the one with unlimited tethering.

The part nobody warns you about: the subway is a data system

New Yorkers navigate the subway by feel. You won't, and that's fine — but it means the subway is, for a visitor, a live-data problem. Lines get rerouted on weekends for track work with little warning. Express and local trains share platforms and share confusion. A single station can have a dozen exits, and choosing wrong drops you three blocks from where you meant to be. Late nights thin out the service and change your best route home.

The good news: every underground station has cellular and Wi-Fi coverage, and the tunnels are progressively being wired too, so a transit app can reroute you in real time from the platform instead of after you've surfaced. That capability is worth more in New York than in almost any city on earth, precisely because the system is so unforgiving of a wrong guess.

Five boroughs, one plan

It's worth remembering New York is not just Manhattan. A good day might be brunch in Williamsburg (Brooklyn), a museum in Manhattan, and dinner in Astoria (Queens) — three boroughs, three subway lines, and constant navigation between them. The same eSIM covers all five boroughs, and the whole country beyond, so the East Coast day trips — Philadelphia, DC, Boston — ride on one plan with nothing to reconfigure.

What travelers actually report

On the forums, the New York consensus lands on the same points this guide is built around: people are relieved to skip the airport SIM queue after a long flight, they value that unlimited data means never rationing on a maps-and-rideshare-heavy trip, and — the one that comes up most from international visitors — they're glad they set something up before landing instead of discovering a roaming bill after. Business travelers add that it's a reliable fallback when hotel Wi-Fi buckles during a conference.

Straight answers

Is it really cheaper than roaming? For most international visitors, yes and by a lot — a week of unlimited is $26.13 with the code, versus per-day roaming that adds up fast. The only exception is if your home plan already includes cheap US roaming, which is worth checking before you decide.

Does it work underground and across all five boroughs? Yes — stations are covered, tunnels increasingly so, and coverage spans all five boroughs plus the rest of the US on one plan.

Do I keep my own number? Yes. The eSIM is data-only, so your home SIM stays active for calls and texts — which matters for the 2FA codes you'll hit constantly.

What if I'm also doing Canada or Mexico? Get the North America eSIM instead of the USA-only one — it covers all three on a single plan.

Which airports does it cover? JFK, LaGuardia, and Newark — you're connected the moment you land at any of them.

The bottom line

New York doesn't punish you for lacking a yacht; it punishes you for lacking a plan — a data plan, specifically, and ideally one you chose on purpose instead of one that switched itself on at the jet bridge. Set up a Holafly eSIM before you fly, use THEDUFRESNES for up to 26% off, and land in the city already ahead of the roaming trap.

👉 Get your Holafly eSIM for New York — code THEDUFRESNES

More from The Dufresnes: YouTube · thedufresnestravel.com